Steven Pinker believes there are understandable reasons for todays women to kill their newborns, or neonates. He has less of a problem with hunter gatherer women committing the same act. His beleifs are that everyone should stop to understand what would lead a woman to do such a thing and it’s okay to understand the facts, but not necessarily forgive. For example, poor health of the baby or not being bothered to ass another child to her presents pack of children. Pinker is very open minded however, on the other hand, the doctors reasons are so negative. The authors ending statements are asking about what a full personhood really is. There would be no real answer for that. All you have are you opinions when it comes to the statement.
Aurthor Bruce Chapman was very angry with the article “Why they Kill Their Newborns” and it’s author Steven Pinker. Chapman was upset with the approach Pinker was trying to give off. He claims the changing of negative words try and change readers opinions without them even realizing it. The major reason why Chapman despised Pinkers article is that Pinker mostly put the blame of neoniticides on the hunter gatherer ancestors. Chapman does not believe women who kill their babies are just obeying their instints. No way did they learn that from their ancestors. Chapman does have his judgements when it comes to killing newborns. He thinks it’s evil and breaking of the religious moral code.
These articles have changed the little views I did have about the situation. I do really believe that the women who do this are sick in some way. They snap into this certain person who can do this to a newborn child and completely snap out of it.